Why Is Self-Storage So Expensive These Days? [2024 Guide]

Ever feel like those storage unit prices are out of control? You’re not alone. It seems like every month, the cost goes up, even if you’re just keeping some old furniture or boxes of stuff there.

So, why is self-storage so expensive?

It turns out there are a few reasons self-storage has become so pricey. Location is a big one — those prime spots near the city come at a premium. Demand’s gone up, too, as people accumulate more and need places to put it all. And the big storage chains? Let’s just say they’re not giving up profits easily.

So, while you’re forking over another 20 bucks a month for storage space, know it’s not just you. We’ll break down exactly why self-storage costs an arm and a leg these days and what you can do about it.

The Rising Costs of Self-Storage

As you’ve probably noticed, the cost of a storage unit has skyrocketed recently. Gone are the days of $50–$100 per month for a small unit. Now, you’re looking at an average of $180 per month in many areas, although our 25 sqft unit only costs $100 in Yonkers, New York.

In a nutshell, the increasing cost of self-storage units is largely due to corporations buying up multiple facilities and the surge in demand.

Greedy Conglomerates

Large companies have been buying out independent storage facilities and jacking up the prices. They know storage is in high demand, especially in populated cities, so they can get away with raising rates. These big corporations are in the business of making money—prioritizing it over providing affordable storage solutions for customers—hence their desire to maximize profit as much as possible.

Surge in Demand

As more people seek out extra space, the demand for storage units climbs, leading to an uptick in pricing, particularly where competition is sparse. In some locations, storage facilities are a dime a dozen, keeping the storage unit cost relatively stable. However, in areas where they’re few and far between, prices can soar in response to rising demand. This location-based variability means that while some places like Yonkers offer reasonable rates, others see steep increases due to the limited number of facilities available to meet the growing need for storage.

Promotional Pricing Pitfalls

When initially renting a storage unit, you might snag a great deal due to promotional pricing aimed at attracting new customers. However, these rates are often temporary.

Once the promotional period ends, facility owners look to recoup their profits, which can result in a sudden and significant hike in storage units’ cost. This can be costly for consumers who didn’t anticipate the increase when budgeting for their storage needs. It’s essential to read the fine print and ask about long-term costs to avoid unwelcome surprises on your bill.

That said, while the above are generally the reasons for the recent surge in prices, some inherent factors exist that can make the prices of similar storage units differ across facilities.

Why Are Storage Units So Expensive? (The Driving Factors)

Apart from the general need to make a profit and less competition, factors like location, size, and amenities offered may affect the price of a storage unit.

Storage Facility Location

Just like with real estate, where your storage unit is located can really influence the price you pay. If you’re in a big city where space is at a premium, chances are you’ll be paying more for a storage container. This is because land and property costs are higher there, and storage companies pass those costs on to their customers.

Why is self-storage so expensive these days- The Driving Factors

On the flip side, in smaller towns or in the suburbs, where there’s more space and less competition for it, you might find that storage units are much more affordable. So when you’re looking for a storage unit, remember that the “where” is just as important as the “how big” when it comes to how much you’ll be shelling out.

Storage Unit Size

How much storage space you need will also affect the unit price. Smaller units are usually cheaper because they don’t give you much room. But when you need more space, maybe to store furniture or lots of boxes, you’ll have to go for a bigger unit, and that means the price goes up. So, if you have a lot to store, be ready to pay more for that extra space.

Additional Amenities

Some newer storage facilities are more like luxury condos, offering additional amenities like 24-hour security with video monitoring, Wi-Fi, loading docks, carts, packing supplies, and climate control. While beneficial, these amenities also significantly increase the storage company’s overall operating costs, which are then passed onto customers through higher rental fees. While all our storage units in New York are climate-controlled and equipped with state-of-the-art security, they’re still priced affordably.

In the end, you have to weigh the factors that are most important to you against your budget to find a self-storage facility that meets your needs at a price you can afford. With some shopping around, you can likely locate a good option without overspending. And while the rising cost is enough to make you wonder if renting a storage unit is worth it, there are certain benefits, especially for businesses.

Is Self-Storage Worth It?

Self-storage may seem like an expensive luxury, but for many people, it’s a necessity and a solid investment. Think about it — where else will you stash those boxes of old records, holiday decorations you only use once a year, or extra inventory for your business? Your home or office probably doesn’t have room for all that extra stuff.

Is Self-Storage Worth It?

Self-storage offers more advantages than just a place to store extra stuff — awesome tax benefits, convenience, safety, and reliability are some of the perks you benefit from when you rent storage units.

Potential Tax Benefits

If you own a small business, self-storage costs may qualify as a tax-deductible business expense. Keep records of your self-storage payments and include them with your other business deductions. For residential customers, self-storage fees may be tax deductible if the unit is used to store household goods while a home is being sold. Check with your tax professional for more details.

Convenience and Flexibility

Self-storage gives you a separate space to organize and access your belongings on your schedule. Units are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, so you can drop in whenever it’s convenient for you. Most facilities also offer month-to-month leases, so you’re not locked into a long contract. This flexibility means you only pay for what you need when you need it.

Safe and Reliable

Self-storage provides a secure place for your valuables with features like coded gate access, surveillance cameras, individual unit alarms, and on-site managers. Your items will be protected from weather, pests, and unauthorized access. Look for a climate-controlled storage if you’re storing sensitive items. For business owners, self-storage also ensures your inventory or documents stay safe but remain easily accessible.

While self-storage isn’t cheap, the benefits of convenience, security, and reliability make the investment worthwhile for many. With some research, you can find a reputable facility that meets your needs at a price that fits your budget.

If you live in or around New York City (we’re based in Yonkers), consider booking a unit at Honey Store It.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is paying for storage worth it?

Paying for storage can be worth it if you’re short on space or between moves. It offers a secure spot for your belongings, letting you declutter while keeping items you’re not ready to part with. It’s a cost-effective solution if the value or need of stored items outweighs the rental fee.

How much should I pay for storage?

The cost of a standard storage unit is generally $60–$180 monthly, while a climate-controlled unit averages $75–$225. Prices can vary based on size, location, and amenities, so choose a unit that fits your budget and meets the specific needs of your stored items.

How much is storage for a year?

On average, renting a storage unit costs around $180 per month, which totals approximately $2,160 annually. Keep in mind that this can fluctuate based on the unit’s size, location, and features like climate control. It’s important to weigh the yearly expense against the necessity and value of what you’re storing.


The rising costs of real estate, the desire to profit, and premium features are the reasons why self-storage is so expensive these days. But when you consider the alternative of trying to cram all your stuff into your home or apartment or constantly moving things in and out of offsite locations, paying a little more for the convenience of a clean, secure self-storage unit close by makes sense.

The bottom line is that we all accumulate more possessions over time. And let’s face it, trying to get rid of it all can be more trouble than it’s worth. So do your research, find the best self-storage deal in your area with the features you need, and make sure to ask about any discounts or special offers that could help trim your monthly bill.

If you’re based in Yonkers or New York, consider booking a unit at Honey Store It today!